Talk

Preventing Publication Bias and Promoting Research Transparency in Economics and Beyond

Professor Edward (Ted) Miguel delivered the keynote lecture at the inaugural Berkeley-Stanford Veridical Data Science Workshop, a pioneering event dedicated to advancing veridical (truthful) data science (VDS). The workshop aimed to promote reproducible and reliable data analysis, foster trustworthy data science, machine learning, and artificial intelligence, and build a community of researchers committed to these principles.

In his lecture, Ted tackled the pervasive issue of publication bias and the challenges of research transparency in the social sciences. Drawing on foundational scientific norms articulated by sociologist Robert Merton—universalism, communality, disinterestedness, and organized skepticism—Ted highlighted the stark gap between these ideals and current practices. He shared insights from his own research in Africa, where pre-analysis plans and open science practices have emerged as critical tools to combat selective reporting.

Ted called for a cultural shift in the scientific community, urging researchers to prioritize truth over career advancement and to embrace transparency as a core value. He introduced the RARE framework (Reporting All Results Efficiently), advocating for full reporting of all hypotheses, even those with null or unpopular results, to combat the “file drawer problem.” Ted’s message was clear: while institutional reforms are essential, lasting change will require a cultural transformation within the scientific community, one that values integrity and truth over sensationalism.

A Framework for Open Policy AnalysisPublished PaperResearch Methodology2020
Go to A Framework for Open Policy Analysis
A study of the impact of data sharing on article citations using journal policies as a natural experimentPublished PaperResearch Methodology2019
Go to A study of the impact of data sharing on article citations using journal policies as a natural experiment
Promoting an Open Research CulturePublished PaperResearch Methodology2015
Go to Promoting an Open Research Culture
Promoting Reproducibility and Replicability in Political SciencePublished Paper2024
Go to Promoting Reproducibility and Replicability in Political Science
Promoting Transparency in Social Science ResearchPublished PaperResearch Methodology2014
Go to Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
Improving Research Transparency in the Social Sciences: Registration, Pre-registration, and Multiple Testing AdjustmentsResearch Methodology2021
Go to Improving Research Transparency in the Social Sciences: Registration, Pre-registration, and Multiple Testing Adjustments
Evidence on Research Transparency in EconomicsPublished PaperResearch Methodology2021
Go to Evidence on Research Transparency in Economics
Research Transparency is on the Rise in EconomicsPublished PaperResearch Methodology2020
Go to Research Transparency is on the Rise in Economics
Transparency, Reproducibility, and the Credibility of Economics ResearchPublished PaperOtherResearch Methodology2018
Go to Transparency, Reproducibility, and the Credibility of Economics Research

Transparent and Reproducible Social Science Research
Go to Transparent and Reproducible Social Science Research

Berkeley Institute for Transparency in the Social Sciences – Research Transparency ForumDavid Brower Center, Berkeley, CADecember 11, 2014
Go to Berkeley Institute for Transparency in the Social Sciences – Research Transparency Forum
Transparency and Reproducibility in Economics ResearchBerkeley, CaliforniaApril 22, 2016
Go to Transparency and Reproducibility in Economics Research
Transparency, Reproducibility and the Credibility of Economics ResearchZeppelin University, GermanyOctober 13, 2017
Go to Transparency, Reproducibility and the Credibility of Economics Research
Preventing Publication Bias and Promoting Research Transparency in Economics and BeyondBerkeley, CaliforniaMay 31, 2024
Go to Preventing Publication Bias and Promoting Research Transparency in Economics and Beyond

An Open Discussion on Promoting Transparency in Social Science ResearchBITSS Blog
Go to An Open Discussion on Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
Aprobando la transparencia y rechazando la polarizaciónLa Tercera
Go to Aprobando la transparencia y rechazando la polarización
Credibilidad y transparencia en políticas públicasLa Tercera
Go to Credibilidad y transparencia en políticas públicas
How to make research better, more transparent, and ethical?Berlin Research 50 Podcast
Go to How to make research better, more transparent, and ethical?
Edward Miguel on the “Replication Crisis” in Economics and How to Fix ItTechnology Policy Institute - Two Think Minimum podcast
Go to Edward Miguel on the “Replication Crisis” in Economics and How to Fix It

Sociologist, Scientist? Towards Transparency, Accountability, and a Sharing CultureThe Good Men Project
Go to Sociologist, Scientist? Towards Transparency, Accountability, and a Sharing Culture
Give Social Sciences Credibility by Demanding Research TransparencyScience 2.0
Go to Give Social Sciences Credibility by Demanding Research Transparency
Making economics transparent and reproducibleAmerican Economic Association
Go to Making economics transparent and reproducible
Science Authors Seek Better Social Science Research TransparencyUC Berkeley News Center
Go to Science Authors Seek Better Social Science Research Transparency