Abstract
We survey recent progress toward research transparency in the social sciences and make the case for standards and practices that help realign scholarly incentives with scholarly values. There is growing appreciation for the advantages of experimentation in the social sciences, but accompanying these changes is a growing sense that incentives, norms, and institutions under which social science operates undermine gains from improved research design. We describe promising, bottom-up innovations in the social sciences, including the three core practices of: disclosure; registration and preanalysis plans; and open data and materials. We also assess common objections to the move toward greater transparency, and argue that new practices need to be implemented in a way that does not stifle creativity or create excess burden.
[Link to abstract] [Link to PDF reprint] [Link to full text]
Related Content
Research
- A Framework for Open Policy Analysis
- A study of the impact of data sharing on article citations using journal policies as a natural experiment
- Destructive Behavior, Judgment, and Economic Decision-making under Thermal Stress
- Pre-results Review at the Journal of Development Economics: Lessons Learned
- Promoting an Open Research Culture
- Research Transparency is on the Rise in Economics
- Reshaping Institutions: Evidence on Aid Impacts Using a Preanalysis Plan
- Transparency and Reproducibility: Conceptualizing the Problem (Chapter 6) and Potential Solutions (Chapter 7)
- Transparency, Reproducibility, and the Credibility of Economics Research
Books
Articles
- An Open Discussion on Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
- Measuring ethnic preferences: New experimental evidence
Talks
- Berkeley Institute for Transparency in the Social Sciences - Research Transparency Forum
- Ethical Economics for a World in Conflict
- Fifth Annual Symposium on Computing for Development (ACM-DEV) 2014
- Innovations in Open Science in Economics
- Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
- Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
- Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
- Promoting Transparency in Social Science Research
- Research Transparency and Reproducibility in Economics and Beyond
- Reshaping Institutions: Evidence on Aid Impacts Using a Pre-analysis Plan (UC Berkeley)
- Reshaping Institutions: Evidence on Aid Impacts Using a Preanalysis Plan (Stanford)
- Reshaping Institutions: Evidence on External Aid and Local Collective Action
- Transparency and Reproducibility in Economics Research
- Transparency and Reproducibility in Economics Research
- Transparency, Reproducibility and the Credibility of Economics Research
Media
- Are deworming programmes beneficial?
- Call for Better Social Science Research Transparency
- Call for Better Social Science Research Transparency
- Call for Better Social Science Research Transparency
- Deworming: An informed debate requires a careful look at the data
- Errors in Experiments, Incorrect Conclusions Plague Social Science Research, Paper States
- Errors, Inexact Standards Cited in Research
- Facebook Apologizes For Manipulation; Data Research Likely To Go On
- Facebook Apologizes For Manipulation; Data Research Likely To Go On
- Fish Oil : Heart Disease :: Microcredit : Women’s Empowerment?
- Give Social Sciences Credibility by Demanding Research Transparency
- How re-analysing the data of scientific research can change the findings
- Incentives for open science: New prizes to encourage research integrity and transparency in social science
- January 3 "Science" Magazine Featured: Calls for Transparency in the Social Sciences
- La Economía Tiene Problemas de Rigor Científico
- La Economía Tiene Problemas de Rigor Científico
- La Economía Tiene Problemas de Rigor Científico
- La Economía Tiene Problemas de Rigor Científico
- La Economía Tiene Serios Problemas de Rigor Científico
- La Economía Tiene Serios Problemas de Rigor Científico
- Making economics transparent and reproducible
- New Prizes Will Recognize and Reward Transparency in Social Science Research
- New research debunks merits of global deworming programmes
- Replication research promotes open discourse
- Science Authors Seek Better Social Science Research Transparency
- Scientists Are Hoarding Data And It’s Ruining Medical Research
- Scientists Are Hoarding Data And It’s Ruining Medical Research
- Study throws doubt on education benefit of deworming children
- The Economics of Change
- The Economics of Change
- Why Economics is Having a Replication Crisis
- Why Null Results Rarely See the Light of Day
- Why you can't trust journalism
- Worms Win, Kids Lose? Our Statement.